City of heroes scrapper vs brute. Jun 5, 2021 · Jumpstar's Scrapper PvE Build Compendium.
City of heroes scrapper vs brute. 6% of their maximum HP regenerated per second. Brute is a good middle ground. On a sentinel for example that offensive form really helps make up the damage loss (can't do anything about the target caps though) while efficient form + defensive adaptation can let you recover a good chunk of your endurance while cycling AoEs. I ended up ditching my bio tanker in favor of a brute flavor with spines/bio, and it's easily my second favorite brute i've ever made (spines has a janky attack animation that sort of feels stilted, not the build's fault, just a personal preference). The updates have brought me back in force and back when I played previously I had a moderately high level brute. In hand to hand, no other hero can compare. You do lack ranged attacks, which could leave you vulnerable to hit-and Or remember when the Hami raids would call on a /Regen scrapper to tank Hami (usually with a flying pocket-healer for backup) and all Tankers were relegated to Giant Monster duty around the rim of the bowl, watching in shame while the biggest baddie in the game was being tanked by a Regen scrapper? Yeaheven I’ll admit it. Summary and Analysis of Brute Powersets; Archetypes documentation on official City of Villains site; Official City of Heroes Manual as a PDF file Dark vs Electric comes down mostly to utility, both being Resist sets with additional tricks to round out their abilities, and having their Immobilize protection in a weird power. The Tanker buff does not make eclipse the Brute as a damage dealer, it just makes Tankers more effective and solo-friendly than they were before. Now I dont want this to be a Scrapper vs Brute thread, but he brought up a good point, Opressive Gloom and cloak of fear stop a Brute from getting the fury that is needed in battle. If you just want raw numbers go scrapper. What the brute primarily gains over the scrapper is more hp, and significantly better threat through punchvoke. Dual Blades can be quite devastating on a Scrapper or Brute if played properly, but it has a steep learning curve to get the rhythm right. so it's better to use IOs to buff defense to pair with the high res, then take an offensive set that has def boosting attacks like katana, staff or titan Fiery Melee allows you to attack with fire, and even conjure up flaming melee weapons. Similarly, activated healing powers are as well. Jack-of-all-trades, master-of-none. However, it looks like Brutes have comparable DPS (and even advantages with some powersets--I seem to recall reading that Fire DoTs benefit from Fury, but not a Scrapper's crit). The scrapper is more fun, but also I’m not a huge fan of elec melee, it doesn’t have much bang. I don't think there's that much else to say there, you've nailed it. Brute build fury as they fight which increases their damage. If you're willing to twink out and constantly maintain Fury, a Brute will generally do better, but if you prefer a more casual game, Scrappers will be the stronger choice. I enjoyed savage on my scrapper since i overused rending flurry while leveling to make quick work of trash mobs. And you might not want to always use Rage, because Rage has negative May 23, 2023 · This section contains information about changes that took place in Homecoming: City of Heroes/Villains. A Brute is sort of a cross between a Scrapper and a Tanker, more damage than a Tanker and more survivability than a Scrapper. Invincibility is replaced by Reinforced, which doesn't rely on mobs in melee range for extra defense/ToHit). I really want to play a Titan Weapons toon but I am wondering if it would be more fun to play a scrapper or brute. It is provided for historical purposes. Welcome home! First question: Do you prioritize damage or survivability? If you want damage first, go Scrapper, survivability: Tank Homecoming buffed the AoE and target caps of Tankers so that if you use an attack set with lots of AoE you can defeat a ton of minions while attacking the boss. Essentially, Scrappers have a higher baseline, Brutes have higher potential. 71 HP regenerated per second. EA is much better on a scrapper than a brute because of the stealth. 3000% Regeneration on a level 50 Scrapper is relative to that 100% number, so it's 12. All said, with a good IO set brute and tanker are very close to each other (survival wise). Scrappers possess Critical Strike capability. wp is the definitive low maintenance secondary. The Scrapper Archetype is a melee-focused DPS Archetype. With all ATs open to all sides I'm now more seriously looking at scrappers as well. With Electric Armor, you master this simultaneously damaging and protective force of nature in order to shock your foes while shielding yourself. Scrapper can get a good amount of survival in an IO build, but they cannot reach brute/tanker levels. I was going to go scrapper because of sweet crits but those extra 500 HP at 50 and 90% resist vs 75% resist and your points convinced me that this would be a good combo for my brute instead of making another scrapper. Powers like Soul Drain, Follow Up, and Blinding Feint on Scrappers will provide more damage compared to the equivalent powers on a Brute. Resources the scrapper could have spent on more damage. Their higher HP makes more out of the Regen than a scrapper, but I don't think they out damage a scrapper. Tank is like a warrior in plate armor. Even scrapper has a taunt aura, making it an excellent choice for damage. It was rough in the 30s and I racked up so much debt, but now that I'm IO'd up (and have some psi resist) it feels invincible. Then this overview of the Brutes video Staff/WP Brute (solid all the way as you level, slow teens) SS/WP Brute (painfully slow start until you solve your end problems with QR, Stamina, Physical Perfection and a number of Performance Shifter, Numina, Miracle, etc procs). Manipulating power to your advantage, this new set allows you to harness electric energy to do your Feb 29, 2024 · Fury was adjusted to be more team-friendly and Brute Damage Scale and Damage Cap were adjusted in Issue 26, Page 4. It works fine on scrapper, but w/ meltdown allowing you to hit the 90% hardcap on brutes for a significant amount of time, the set is noticeably more valuable for brute than scrapper. Feb 29, 2024 · The Scrapper is a fierce melee combatant. The Scrapper's aptitude for melee is countered by a lack of ranged attacks. 0. Otherwise they are pretty similar. It is a Tanker secondary power set and a Brute primary power set in City of Villains, and as of Issue 12, a Scrapper primary powerset in City of Heroes. Except that the Scrapper can crit, and the Brute can't. 500 * 1. What secondary would you pair with SM on a Brute? Elec Armor, Bio Armor and Dark Armor stand out to me. Your mobility will be screwy if you get the camera angle wrong and brutes need to be close to the fight and attacked a lot. Psi lets me 1 or 2shot most critters, plus on a scrapper it has the cone and AoE attacks for Claws is a Melee Primary power set, though it does contain one Ranged attack. On top of that, they have a higher HP pool and a potential 90% Resist cap in late game. It's absolutely a boost, it's not like "Click this and turn into God" the way like Barrier Core is. Tank damage cap is 500%, brute is 700%. That leaves scrapper or brute. Claws are bones or blades that extend from your hands and cause Lethal damage. Scrappers possess Critical strike scrapper = deal more dmg on avg / in general ; bit less tanky ; still durable brute - fury - starts low, builds up by atkn or getn atkd, u deal more dmg with more fury, decays if not fightn scrapper - crits - 5-10% chance to deal 2x dmg, slightly more with ATOs and some powers vs LTs and above thats basically it I don't mind it too much if a set is not absolutely uber powerful either (heck, I was having fun back in the day with a ninja daycare MM), but from the sounds of it, it may be a bit too busy for me to play as a Brute (I tend to go into brutelock quite often), will likely go Scrapper for this one. Their melee attacks have a chance to sometimes do That said typically resistance based sets are better on a tanker or brute as opposed to a scrapper or stalker as 90% resistance is definitely better than 75% resistance. Sep 7, 2015 · If given the choice to play a scrapper or brute I will play a brute every single time and twice on Sundays. Main Menu. Brute is like a rogue that can wear chainmail. Tanker, probably similar due to the higher AoE target cap and taunting. Jan 14, 2024 · In City of Heroes: Homecoming, players can choose from 15 Archetypes when designing their custom Hero/Villain. as claws is fast and fluid, you'll be able to fully focus on pumping out dmg and not have to put much thought into sustain other than positioning, and maybe popping the occasional purp insp if needed. Street/WP Brute (solid as you go like Staff) SS/WP is the easiest/dumbest. Higher resist cap and better taunt from primary makes them a better choice to tank, though. Lousy damage compared to the scrapper, lousy survivability compared to the tank. 8 ranged damage) means they can clear mobs a lot faster. My brute often runs at close to 500% +dam from inspirations through most of a farm map with good drops that combine well, and doublehit feels alot like having two extra damage IOs in each power. Radiation armor is great, but I would recommend using it on brute (or tank, though I'm meh on tanks in general) to get the higher resistance cap. Scrappers, in City of Heroes, and Stalkers and Brutes in City of Villains, have access to Claws. IMO, Energy Aura is also a powerset that is not particularly well-suited to anyone but Stalkers. From reading about Bio armour with mini FX it thematically fits quite well the only question is do i go Rad melee or Dark melee! Tank if you're on HC. The Scrapper's aptitude for melee is countered by a total lack of long distance attacks. 5 times that of the Brute. Regeneration offers almost no actual damage resistance, but your Hit Point and Endurance Regeneration can Electric Armor is a Tanker primary powerset and a Scrapper, Brute and Sentinel secondary powerset, and as of Issue 12 a Stalker secondary powerset. So the real damage cap is 775% for the Brute, and 825% for the Scrapper, which balances the Brute's higher resistance cap. I chose scrapper because/DA scrapper was my first toon on live and I wanted to recreate the experience. Had to reupload due to audio cutting out past the three minute mark. Tanker is tankier, brute is a quicker and more rushed playstyle. Thanks! Archetype wise, both Brute and Tanker would be good choices for the reason you've outlined (damage vs. An example from my experience is my elec/shield scrapper vs elec/shield stalker vs shield/elec tank vs energy/shield brute vs energy/energy scrapper. team buffs very often will cover the extra DEF anyway so it would mostly be for soloing harder content that you'd ever need to worry If you want good dps and to survive well go brute. The following table shows which Jun 5, 2021 · Jumpstar's Scrapper PvE Build Compendium. 42% of their Maximum Health (1339) regenerated per second. If you are new to City of Heroes or a returning player and want information on the Brute archetype for City of Heroes. Really, the solo-friendly choice here is Brute. Tanker. If you’re having trouble with end, switch to efficient stance, if you need to be Tanky, defensive, etc. What I just said is not absolute, and a lot will depend on the AT you pick and how you build your character. yes, she lives up to that name, as literally nothing can take her down. Definitely both would be even tankier because of the resist caps. It looks like it was MADE for a Brute. Currently at 49 on a Psi/EA scrapper and I'm loving it. Bio armor is a great set period. . However, after looking at it a bit, it seems like Savage Melee is an outlier. All have a damage aura to ramp up fury. For information regarding the health regeneration gameplay mechanic, see Health Regeneration. With strong offensive power sets designed to inflict pain and impressive defenses to take it, you're the best there is in a straight melee fight. May 14, 2023 · 28 (Brute) 28 (Scrapper) 28 (Sentinel) 28 (Stalker) 22 (Tanker) Effects: Point Blank Area of Effect Foe Moderate Damage Over Time(Toxic), -Defense(All) Ally +Health, +Heal over Time Enhancements: Enhance Accuracy Enhance Damage Enhance Defense Debuff Reduce Endurance Cost Enhance Heal Increase Attack Rate Enhance Taunt Effectiveness (Brute Baseline (100%) Regeneration on a level 50 Scrapper is 0. those that are "better" on a brute? The base damage of a Scrapper is 1. AoE radius). Or 5. Fiery Melee is available as a primary set for Brutes. The lightweight, natural feel of claws gives this power set a reduced Endurance cost and faster attack rate than other similar melee sets You can look at the difference between the tanker and brute stats and passive ability on the wiki. News: SMF - Just Installed! City of Heroes This article is about the Regeneration Powerset. May 25, 2023 · 18 (Brute) 18 (Scrapper) 24 (Tanker) Effects: Melee Foe -Defense(All), -Resistance(All) Enhancements: Enhance Accuracy Enhance Damage Enhance Defense Debuff Reduce Endurance Cost Increase Attack Rate Enhance Taunt Effectiveness (except Scrapper) Set Categories: Melee Damage: Accurate Defense Debuff: Defense Debuff: Taunt (except Scrapper Aug 3, 2021 · Overview. You have a larger HP pool to survive with and Burn will keep you alive better because dead enemies don't fight back and scrapper burn will cause enemies to run away, whereas Brute Burn will taunt enemies to stand there and cook. g. I've had this idea of a poison/disease character for a long time now and have remade it like 4 times but I've not looked at melee characters. Also, this guide is no FYI, your comment is what convinced me to change my tw/will from a scrapper to a brute at the last minute. It has the old defensive set Psi Hole, which matters much less for Stalkers than for any other melee AT. 95 melee damage modifier--brute starts at . Or 168. This set was added to the game for Brutes , Scrappers , Stalkers , and Tankers in Issue 11 . Is there a good guideline of what sets (or combination thereof) that are "better" on a scrapper vs. Managing Brute's fury will be a pain in the ass with Hover on. I have all three positional defenses at 50% on the tank and 90% sl resist, with slots left over for fun powers like hover and fold space and filling out taunt a bit, or being able to spam fold Brute and Scrapper WP are largely the same thing notably, Scrapper WP is one of those rare Scrap armors with a taunt effect, which is always nice to keep mobs clustered. Both sets also famously resist endurance drain (laugh at Sappers). Aug 15, 2021 · Nice Fight - With higher base health things that add health are typically better on a brute. Let's talk about Brute vs. Even if you stick both classes at their respective damage caps, the Brute caps out at nearly 30% more damage. 58 HP regenerated per second. Regeneration is a Scrapper, Brute, Stalker and Sentinel secondary power set. Even in non-farming content you should go Brute. With powerful close-quarters combat that can be strengthened by the Archetype's Critical Hit mechanic, the What that means is while the scrapper is capped to 75% resist the Brute isn't necessarily going to get to his cap of 90 without putting extra resources into it. Meanwhile, fully enhanced Electric Armor will give a Brute 90% Energy damage resistance compared to 75% on a Scrapper. And it's not just because of Street Justice either, Invulnerability is much easier to softcap on a Stalker than on a Scrapper/Brute (e. 33% more damage overall. (Makin' Bacon on Excelsior). In hand to hand combat, no other hero can compare. Protracted battles only make you mad, and the madder you get, the more damaging your attacks become. 8 to . May 24, 2023 · 2 (Brute) 2 (Scrapper) 2 (Stalker) 4 (Tanker) Effects: Point Blank Area of Effect, Minor Damage over Time(Toxic) Foe -Recharge, -Speed Enhancements: Enhance Accuracy Enhance Damage Reduce Endurance Cost Increase Attack Rate Enhance Slow Enhance Taunt Effectiveness (Brute/Tanker only) Set Categories: Melee AoE Damage: Slow Movement: Taunt (Brute If you want to use rad for a brute or scrapper, i suggest not going for maxing resistances, you won't do it in a brute, and scrappers res cap of 75 is too low to effectively off tank with it. But the Scrapper is not as resilient as the Tanker, and might find himself in a little trouble if he heedlessly wades into combat. That said, I have a elec/shield brute and a scrapper. City of Heroes » Scrappers and Brutes . That said yes a brute can be built to achieve pretty high resistances. Scrappers are the most straightforward with Critical Hit being automatic and scaling to the threat (better crit chance vs tougher foes). i have Less Damage on second Build :( That combo is arguably better on a Stalker. SMF 2. I stopped playing it mid-20's. These archetypes offer different specializations and allow for different styles of play. Brute's need either heavy +dmg sources from teammates or to be tanking a large number of enemies to hit scrapper levels of damage (fury generates faster at lower values, but is harder to maintain at higher, and you need near max to close the damage gap) The main differences between the three are that the base/max HP values go Brute > Scrapper > Stalker, and their inherit abilities handle the damage side of the equation much differently. See Also. Want to be unkillable? Go Tanker? Do big damage? Scrapper it is. - Things that can push your resistances over 75% (tier 9 god modes, accolades, barrier destiny, team buffs, etc) aren't wasted on a brute, as they are on a scrapper. On a Brute, you'll still do good damage on the character even if you don't use Rage in Super Strength because a greater proportion of your damage output comes from the Brute's Fury mechanic. Yes, I am aware I said "critical strike" instead of critical hit. Jan 18, 2024 · Archetype Overview. 75, and . If you're adamant with sticking with Hover, scrapper. Archetypes; Brute Strategy; External Links. The extra survivability greatly outweighs the minor extra damage brute's do. 15 Actually it seems to be tailor-made for everyone with access to it, individually. My Savage Melee is a Tanker largely because I wanted a character that I could enjoy the bigger i27/Homecoming Tanker radius and target caps on, and I already Brutes live to fight, and as a Brute, you will revel in hand-to-hand combat. Plus, the buffs they've received (. Apr 26, 2016 · Even with the same enhancements, Fury doesn't modify the damage post-enhancements, it's a % buff to the base power damage, so having a damage enhancement on a Brute power vs a Scrapper power, the Scrapper will get even more damage increase than the brute, so the more enhanced a power is, the more fury the brute would need to match the Scrapper Savage melee uses your passive better but the rending flurry AoE is significantly smaller comapred to scrapper's iirc. I think it would probably be better overall on a Brute, especially due to the taunt auras. The brute's damage was super-disappointing. The Scrapper is a fierce melee combatant. My main is now that 50+3 TW/bio scrapper. The critical hits of a scrapper sound really appealing especially while swinging a ginormous weapon! Meanwhile, a brute’s fury mechanic also sounds really fun and I’d play out a barbarian type toon. Brutes do get slightly more mileage out of WP due to larger health pool synergising with +HP and +Regen effects, plus higher res cap synergising with the S/L res from WP Faster Fury generation somewhat makes up for not being a scrapper, but its not going to close the damage gap entirely. 5 = 750, so the Brute Cap is 3. From my rather limited experiences with both, I can say that Stalker is a lot more fun to play than Scrapper, mostly because you have some control of how and when you crit, so you can direct them at the big threats, while the Scrapper it's just "run in, attack everything until death, repeat", the fact that the Scrapper is sturdier ironically The Brute in that scenario will still do ~40% more damage. Main Menu Home; Search Log in; Sign up; Nov 10, 2024, 08:21 PM. Sep 8, 2010 · Hello everyone, I've just recently rolled a Dark/Dark Brute, and was teaming with somone who said that Dark/Dark scrappers are better. Fiery Melee powers tend to set foes ablaze for added damage over time. Regeneration lets you regenerate more quickly from damage and effects. dsdsyi qelgy plpd tpnyd waji izhff wwwx byxxao xddb dwdd